🔄
top of page

Parenting a Neurodivergent Child: Why Standard Parenting Advice Doesn't Work

Do you find yourself saying “I thought parenting would look different.”


Your child refuses to sit at the dinner table. Bedtime takes three hours. Simple requests trigger meltdowns that last for forty minutes. You've tried reward charts, consequences, the gentle parenting scripts everyone swears by — none of it works.


The problem isn't your parenting. The problem is that every strategy you've been given assumes your child's nervous system works like a neurotypical child's. It doesn't.


Parenting a neurodivergent child — whether they have ADHD, autism, PDA, or a combination — means recognising that standard parenting advice was designed for brains that process the world differently to your child's. What looks like defiance is often a nervous system under threat. What looks like manipulation is often a child doing the only thing that feels manageable in that moment.


This isn't about lowering your expectations or "giving in." It's about understanding how your child's brain actually functions, and adjusting your approach accordingly.


Why Neurotypical Parenting Strategies Fail Neurodivergent Children


Most parenting advice is built on neurotypical assumptions about how children learn, regulate emotions, and respond to consequences.


The standard expectations:

  • Children should sit still during meals

  • They should follow instructions after one or two reminders

  • They should manage disappointment without major emotional reactions

  • They should learn from consequences

  • They should respond to reward charts and praise


But neurodivergent children often can't meet these expectations — not because they're being difficult, but because their nervous systems are wired differently.


The Nervous System Explanation


Polyvagal theory, developed by Dr Stephen Porges, explains why consequences and reward charts often fail for neurodivergent children. The theory describes how our autonomic nervous system operates in three states:


Ventral vagal (safe and social): The child can think, learn, connect, and respond to reason. This is where consequences, conversations, and problem-solving actually work.


Sympathetic (fight or flight): The child's body perceives threat. They might argue, refuse, run away, or lash out. Logic and reasoning don't work here because the prefrontal cortex — the part of the brain that handles planning, empathy, and decision-making — is offline.


Dorsal vagal (shutdown): The child's system has moved past fight-or-flight into collapse. They might seem disconnected, unresponsive, or like they "don't care." They're not being defiant. Their nervous system has shut down to protect them.


Here's what this means in practice: When your child melts down over socks feeling wrong, or shuts down when asked to do homework, they're not choosing to be difficult. Their nervous system has detected a threat (sensory overwhelm, demand overload, unpredictability) and responded accordingly.


Telling them to "calm down," "think about their choices," or "use their words" is asking them to access parts of their brain that aren't available when they're dysregulated.


What Low-Demand Parenting Actually Means


Low-demand parenting isn't about removing all expectations or avoiding boundaries. It's about reducing unnecessary pressure so your child can engage with the world in ways that feel safe and manageable to their nervous system.


This approach is particularly relevant for children with pathological demand avoidance (PDA), but it's useful for any neurodivergent child who struggles with perceived demands or control.


What This Looks Like in Practice


Offering choices instead of instructions Instead of: "Put your shoes on, we're leaving in five minutes." Try: "Which shoes feel okay today — trainers or boots?"


This shifts the interaction from a demand (which might trigger fight-or-flight) to collaboration (which keeps the child's nervous system in a safer state).


Reducing urgency around non-essential tasks Ask yourself: Does this actually matter right now? If your child refuses to wear a coat, will they genuinely be harmed, or will natural consequences (feeling cold) teach them more effectively than a battle?


Picking fewer battles doesn't mean you're failing as a parent. It means you're prioritising connection and nervous system safety over compliance.


Building connection before making requests "Let's have a cuddle before we get ready" or "Can I sit with you whilst you brush your teeth?" signals safety before introducing a demand. Dr Mona Delahooke's research on co-regulation shows that children can't move into a calm, receptive state without first experiencing safety in relationship.


Using indirect language Direct demands can feel threatening to a dysregulated nervous system. Indirect approaches soften the perceived pressure:

  • "I wonder if your body needs breakfast yet" instead of "Come and eat breakfast"

  • "The bathroom's free if you need it" instead of "Go and brush your teeth"


This isn't manipulation. It's meeting your child's nervous system where it actually is, rather than where you wish it was.


Reframing the "Shoulds" of Parenting


Society tells you that adapting to your child's needs is making excuses. That "kids should toughen up." That if you don't enforce consequences consistently, your child will never learn.

But neurodivergent parenting isn't about making excuses. It's about making accommodations so your child can function without their nervous system being in a constant state of threat.


Common Reframes


"They should be able to handle this by now"

Reframe: Their nervous system is telling me this is too much for them right now. Pushing through won't build resilience — it will deepen the stress response.


"If I adapt everything to suit them, they'll never cope in the real world"

Reframe: Teaching them to understand their own nervous system now gives them tools to advocate for themselves later. I'm not removing challenges — I'm teaching them how to navigate challenges without collapsing.


"Other parents don't have to do this"

Reframe: Other parents aren't parenting my child. Comparing my child to neurotypical children tells me nothing useful about what my child needs.


"I should be more consistent with consequences"

Reframe: Consistency matters, but not if I'm consistently using strategies that dysregulate my child's nervous system. Connection builds behaviour change more effectively than control.


When You're a Neurodivergent Parent Yourself


Parenting a neurodivergent child whilst managing your own ADHD or autism adds another layer of complexity. You might struggle with:


  • Emotional regulation when your child is dysregulated

  • Executive function challenges (planning meals, managing routines, keeping track of school requirements)

  • Sensory overwhelm from your child's noise, demands, or physical needs

  • Guilt about not being the calm, regulated parent you think you should be


If you're finding it difficult to regulate your own nervous system whilst supporting your child's, ADHD coaching can help you develop strategies that work for both of you. You can't co-regulate your child if you're constantly dysregulated yourself.


This Isn't About Fixing Your Child


Parenting a neurodivergent child isn't about making them behave like neurotypical children. It's about understanding how their brain and nervous system work, and creating an environment where they can function without being in a constant state of fight, flight, or shutdown.


When you reduce demands, build connection before making requests, and work with your child's nervous system rather than against it, you're not failing. You're parenting the child you have, not the child you expected.


That's not low standards. It's good parenting.


Resources and Further Support


📌 Sign up to Download a free copy of my Neurodiversity Parenting Activity Guide for strategies that actually work.




📌 If your teen has just been diagnosed with ADHD, my self-paced online course, ADHD & Me, is designed to help them understand their ADHD, recognise how it affects their daily life, and discover strategies that actually work for them.



📌 If you're a neurodivergent parent struggling to manage your own regulation whilst parenting, book a discovery call to explore whether ADHD coaching might help.





🔗 Research & Further Reading

📚 Polyvagal Theory & Emotional Regulation 

– Dr. Stephen Porges


📚 Co-Regulation & Emotional Development 

– Dr. Mine Conkbayir


📚 Low-Demand Parenting & Demand Avoidance



Three people joyfully pose on a car hood under a clear blue sky, with one using a selfie stick. Green trees in the background.


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page